The first person I talked to about Lyndon’s murders and death was a reporter for a Denver newspaper.
On December 29th, 2021, in the early afternoon, I opened my inbox and saw an email from her, with the subject line “Roman McClay” (Lyndon’s pen name). I googled “Roman McClay.” Skimmed an account or two of what he’d done. Then, per her request, called her up.
In that conversation, I told the truth. The whole truth. About why I was shocked but not surprised.
And then I lied.
I denied that my exchanges with Lyndon had involved flirtation. I insisted we were just friends. While recalling a slew of interactions—via text, phone, email—that had indeed felt like flirting.
Why did I lie?
Because I did not want to embarrass my husband by admitting in public that, while married to him, I’d nursed a crush on another man. (Why am I admitting this now? Because I now understand that my crushes—while related, sometimes, to my current story about our relationship—have nothing to do with him.)
And because I was ashamed of having crushes. Especially the kind that went unrequited.
I had told Lyndon, outright—not once, but twice—that I had a crush on him. Both times, he’d responded sweetly and appreciatively. But he’d never acknowledged that he was flirting with me.
I developed my first crush when I was six years old.
I still remember the boy’s name. He was a year ahead of me at Holy Name School. He lived a few blocks closer to Holy Name than I did. Sometimes I caught up with him, on the way to school, and we race-walked. Some weeks I attended the 5:30 mass on Saturday evening, so I could sit behind him and gaze at the back of his head. I never told him I liked him.
I’ve been crushing ever since. Even though, according to my brain, this penchant of mine is ridiculous. Pathetic. And dangerous. Or, at least, highly convenient.
What is a crush, anyway?
According to my 1976 dictionary, it’s “an intense and usually passing infatuation.” (As opposed to a mild and/or lasting infatuation? Does such a thing exist?)
For me, a crush manifests as intense interest.
When I have a crush on someone, I’m acutely aware of his whereabouts (if we’re in the same place). I crave contact but also avoid it. I play games: How can I put myself in his path, then get him to make the first move by pretending not to see him? I desire touch (as opposed to sex) and fantasize, in detail, about how that might happen. I use my thoughts about him to distract myself (I focus on him when he’s not around; I check my device(s) for messages, if that’s part of how we interact). I fiercely want to connect, but do not bring my full presence to—and therefore cannot thoroughly enjoy—that connection in the moment. I fail to look out for the person, or care for him, or perceive his vulnerabilities, because I’m so busy wondering whether he’ll notice me.
Sounds painful, right?
Yes. And yet, I don’t wish I could prevent myself from ever developing another crush. Or fly back in time and erase past crushes from my life.
Why not?
Because, though painful, they’re also delightful. Intoxicating. Mysterious. Because I value the experience of intense interest. The divine torture of it. The shit I’ve done because of it.
Who would I be, in the throes of an intense interest, without the thought, “I have a crush”? Without my judgment of the interest as pathetic, dangerous, ridiculous?
I would be curious—about the true nature of the relationship. The spirit of the link. Why this man, of all men? What’s my soul up to here? What are we—my soul and I—looking for?
Back in 2018-19, at a Native American Church ceremony that began on New Year’s eve and ended New Year’s Day, I asked the plant medicine why I’d reconnected with Lyndon.
The answer? He was to help me reclaim my wildness, and my ancestry. Also, if not for my tumult with him, and my desire to understand it, I might not have submitted—for the first time—to the risks and rigors of “sitting up,” all night, in ceremony.
The plant also told me that I concocted crushes in an attempt to compensate for missing kin. Had I been born into a clan in the Scottish Highlands—for example—I would have enjoyed a dense weave of relationships with a tangle of men. Instead, I’d tried to make do with a ragged fabric: I’d grown up with my father but had barely known him, as mentor, provider, or protector. Of six half-brothers, I’d grown close to one. I’d seen my maternal grandfather maybe once or twice a year, as a child and a teenager—he’d died when I was fifteen. I’d never met my father’s father (had he died before my birth?). I have two uncles-in-law, and one male cousin. At Zendik, I’d bonded with plenty of men, through work and sex—but most of those ties hadn’t survive our departure from the Farm. The dissolution of our sham family. And anyhow they weren’t kin.
After Lyndon dropped out of sight, circa June 2020, (having invoked Cicada 3301 in his final Tweet), I acknowledged that we might never meet in person. I hated that. So I decided to insert him into my novel, as my protagonist’s brother and sidekick. To bring our characters together, on the page.
I did not make him my protagonist’s love interest. In the book, she doesn’t have one. (As my editor said, the story is “blessedly free of romance.”) What I wanted with Lyndon, as of 2020-21, was kinship. Closeness. Camaraderie.
In my most enduring fantasy of a face-to-face encounter, I glimpsed him, across a porch full of ex-Zendiks, at a Zendik reunion. As I approached, I watched a grin of recognition spread across his face. Then we hugged. Fiercely. (After he died, I dreamed that I was running after him, inside an empty warehouse. I wanted to catch up with him so I could give him a hug.)
I wanted him next to me. In my novel, he could be.
On the surface, since June 2020, my relationship with Lyndon hasn’t changed. We didn’t interact for the last year and a half of his life; we haven’t interacted, on the physical plane, in the two years since his death.
Beneath the surface? It has changed. I now know we will never meet. I will never drop in his hand the three round stones I plucked for him from St. Columba’s Bay, or share with him and Geranium the tiny bottle of Ledaig, or hug him in the flesh.
Also, it’s almost easier to communicate with him, now that he’s dead. Why? Because, as a spirit, he can show up anywhere. He’s always available. And since I no longer fear his anger or seek his favor I can amp up my honesty. Risk total embarrassment. Press any message I want through gaps in the veil.
One morning last December, walking near Earthaven, I said to Lyndon, with tears in my voice, “I want to know you’re walking beside me.”
Minutes later, I realized that just before I’d said that I’d received, on my mostly-nonresponsive-this-deep-in-the-woods flip phone, not one but two “Congratulations!” messages from Airbnb—one announcing a booking covering his birthday, the other announcing a booking starting on mine.
Yes, he’s walking beside me. Yes, he’s talked to me as I’ve drafted novel scenes that have taken twists I hadn’t planned. Yes, he answers my questions, when I ask them aloud, or in writing.
No, I can’t prove this. I simply choose to believe it. It doesn’t do any harm, and I enjoy my life more when I do.
Who is Lyndon to me? Who was he?
A soul mate. A soul I have business with. Some of that business I’ve completed; some remains undone.
We definitely don’t flirt nowadays. I feel no giddiness, no blushing excitement, when I consort with his ghost. But I do feel interest. Fascination. I do sense a link that shimmers my days with a dense and fiery light.


